Are financial crises costly? To answer this question, one should not look at the cost of a bailout, a drop in GDP or missing tax revenue, but at what people care about: consumption. In this regard, the current crisis is too young to be analyzed, but other ones are available. Two recent papers look at this for Japan and Norway.Like Bernie Madoff scandal, perhaps financial crises may be more about transferring or delaying wealth than an actual destruction of wealth. There's even some evidence that recessions are good for filtering out inefficient businesses and growing those that survive.
Yasuyuki Sawada, Kazumitsu Nawata, Masako Ii and Mark Lee use panel data from Japan that spans over the 1997 banking crisis and estimate Euler equation that allow for credit constraints. While in normal times, 7.82% of households are credit constraint, this increases only to 8.44% during the credit crunch. In other words, the ability for households to smooth out consumption was only negligibly affected.
Eilev Jansen studies Norway, but prefers a VAR approach linking current wealth and income to consumption, which appears to work better than Euler equation approaches for the recent years. But again, the impact of the crisis on consumption is negligible: the elasticity of equity income on consumption is 2%.
Friday, June 18, 2010
Costs of the Financial Crisis
Are not as much as you might think:
Thursday, June 17, 2010
Difference Between Humans and Animals, Part VII
In the first post of this series I suggested that trade, maybe I was right. From the Economist Magazine:
humans are the only species capable of innovation. Other animals use tools, and some ants, for example, do specialise at certain tasks. But these skills are not cumulative, and the animals in question do not improve their technologies from generation to generation. Only man innovates continuously.Not only is our ability to hold this new information increasing, but the internet allows the storage and dispersion like never before. Here's part one, two, three, four, five, and six of this continuing series.
But what makes us unique?
Some have suggested that perhaps it is the chemistry of big brains that leads us to tinker. Others that man’s mastery of language or his capacity for imitation and social learning hold the key. Mr Ridley, a zoologist by training, weighs up these arguments but insists, in the end, that the explanation lies not within man’s brain but outside: innovation is a collective phenomenon. The way man’s collective brain grows, he says cheekily, is by “ideas having sex”.
His own theory is, in a way, the glorious offspring that would result if Charles Darwin’s ideas were mated with those of Adam Smith. Trade, Mr Ridley insists, is the spark that lit the fire of human imagination, as it made possible not only the exchange of goods, but also the exchange of ideas. Trade also encouraged specialisation, since it rewarded individuals and communities who focus on areas of comparative advantage. Such specialists, in contrast with their generalist rivals or ancestors, had the time and the incentive to develop better methods and technologies to do their tasks.
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Learning by Teaching: AP US Essays
After my AP US Exam was given, we had about a month left before taking the state exams. So I assigned some research papers. Here are some things I learned while grading them:
- President John Quincy Adams had a foreign born wife.
- The infamous Peggy Eaton affair may have cost South Carolina its only possible president.
- The orignal plan was to kidnap Lincoln and use him to end the Civil War.
- The Union threatened to declare war on any nation that supported the Confederacy, which Britain and France almost did.
- In 1869 Wyoming became the first state to give women suffrage, apparently to encourage more single women to move there.
- The NAACP was started by a group of white people.
- Martin Luther King, Jr. was born Michael Luther King, Jr.
- Ronald Reagan added more trade barriers than any administration since Hoover.
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
How Superstitions Begin
In a famous experiment with pigeons, an automatic feed is set to release at regular intervals with no relation to behavior. This resulted in tricking the birds into repeating the action they did when food is first released:
One bird was conditioned to turn counter-clockwise about the cage, making two or three turns between reinforcements. Another repeatedly thrust its head into one of the upper corners of the cage. A third developed a 'tossing' response, as if placing its head beneath an invisible bar and lifting it repeatedly.This has got me wondering not only what my superstitions are, but what first caused them. Here's a 10 year old girl that refuses to let a shark bite make her superstitious. Just as interesting, apparently luck helps when you believe it. Also related, here's a TED talk by the publisher of Skeptic Magazine on why we believe strange things.
Monday, June 14, 2010
Embracing Mistakes
Though I'm not normally a sports fan, it's been hard to avoid the attention of the World Cup. One of the biggest stories comes from America's tie with England, mostly thanks to a missed block by English goalie Robert Green (video here). He has been getting flack from announcers and fans alike. Even traditional sports like baseball and football can become intense in America, but the World Cup seems to be more like the Olympics than anything else. It's a rare combination of athletics and national patriotism. Mistakes not only let your team down, they let your nation down.
The pressure of professional sports is one of thrilling parts of watching, but it is also a good picture of what the real world is like. This Nike commercial does a great job of showing the short and long term international reactions to World Cup matches. Make a mistake and often you are ridiculed by all. Whether it was careless or intentional, it's often treated the same. To admit you're wrong may even make things worse. There is evidence many women prefer arrogant men.
In a recent article in the Boston Globe, the author describes that our mistakes are actually a result of our greatest strength, inductive reasoning. In any given situation, we can determine not just a possible answer, but a probable one. For example when a student stares at their belly button in class, I infer they are texting. In most cases I am right. Every so often I'm wrong. It is our focus on the wrongs that make us less likely to take the chance. Saving face trumps getting it right.
Here is another real life example from soccer (football). Statistically speaking a goalie is more likely to block a penalty kick if they stay in the middle of the goal. However, it is better for a goalie's reputation to fail while diving to block than to fail standing still. So they dive, either right or left. Similarly, it is optimal for the penalty kicker to aim for the upper third of the goal. Though it is more likely to miss the net completely, it is much less likely to be stopped by a diving goalie. Again, most players avoid this strategy because being blocked by a goalie is more honorable than missing completely.
Placing such a higher weight on failures compared to successes greatly decreases the number of successes. Understanding and accepting that our inductive reasonings skills are mostly right can have huge societal benefits. It helps us understand our own failings and be patient with others' failings. Hopefully it will also help us be weary of those who seem to be absent these mistakes, namely celebrities and politicians.
The pressure of professional sports is one of thrilling parts of watching, but it is also a good picture of what the real world is like. This Nike commercial does a great job of showing the short and long term international reactions to World Cup matches. Make a mistake and often you are ridiculed by all. Whether it was careless or intentional, it's often treated the same. To admit you're wrong may even make things worse. There is evidence many women prefer arrogant men.
In a recent article in the Boston Globe, the author describes that our mistakes are actually a result of our greatest strength, inductive reasoning. In any given situation, we can determine not just a possible answer, but a probable one. For example when a student stares at their belly button in class, I infer they are texting. In most cases I am right. Every so often I'm wrong. It is our focus on the wrongs that make us less likely to take the chance. Saving face trumps getting it right.
Here is another real life example from soccer (football). Statistically speaking a goalie is more likely to block a penalty kick if they stay in the middle of the goal. However, it is better for a goalie's reputation to fail while diving to block than to fail standing still. So they dive, either right or left. Similarly, it is optimal for the penalty kicker to aim for the upper third of the goal. Though it is more likely to miss the net completely, it is much less likely to be stopped by a diving goalie. Again, most players avoid this strategy because being blocked by a goalie is more honorable than missing completely.
Placing such a higher weight on failures compared to successes greatly decreases the number of successes. Understanding and accepting that our inductive reasonings skills are mostly right can have huge societal benefits. It helps us understand our own failings and be patient with others' failings. Hopefully it will also help us be weary of those who seem to be absent these mistakes, namely celebrities and politicians.
Sunday, June 13, 2010
Breakfast Reminds Us We're Rich
As I've said before, if you're reading this, you're rich. But how do you convince your brain? According to a sleep expert, it's breakfast:
But it's more crucial that you eat breakfast first thing in the morning, in what I call a 'metabolic window'. It's a timeframe in which you can give your body an important message. It tells it that in your world there is an adequate supply of food, it can relax, and that it can fall into sleep mode when it needs to.The whole article is full of practical advice on good sleep.
Saturday, June 12, 2010
School Teaches Students to Accept Inequality
I give a test every Friday. According to economist Robin Hanson, I'm teaching my students a valuable lesson:
At school, our kids are rated and ranked far more often than most adults will tolerate, even though this actually slows their learning! It seems that modern schools function in part to help humans overcome their (genetically and culturally) inherited aversions to hierarchy and dominance.Here's how much it changes student perception (links added):
The large majority of 5th graders were strict egalitarians (link), and, remarkably, there were almost no meritocrats (link) at this grade level. In contrast, meritocratism was the dominant position in late adolescence, and the share of strict egalitarians fell dramatically.I wonder, is this lesson on net good or bad, especially when grading could have a negative impact on learning?
Friday, June 11, 2010
Economics of Happiness
I regularly try to remind my readers (and myself) that life is good:
Individual and societal wealth has increased dramatically over the past 50 years. In the United States, for example, real per capita income doubled between 1970 and 2000.So why do we have to be reminded so often?
Life on the Hedonic Treadmill leaves us unfulfilled because it does not address the three consistent challenges to contentment: constant change, competing priorities for our time, and financial uncertainty. Constant change presents evolving views of our present and our future which challenge our view of what is important. We ask: What is important to me? We face many competing priorities for the use of our time and the expectation to produce more in less. We ask: How should I be spending my time? Financial uncertainty presented by job worries, market ups and downs and uncertainty about our life in retirement, drive us to greater levels of concern about both our present financial lives and our long-term financial future. We ask: How should I be dealing with money?The solution wise suggested by the author is that you should get off the treadmill and create your own path to your own goals. That way you can see your progress and be satisfied.
The lack of answers provided by life on the Hedonic Treadmill leaves us vulnerable to suggestion, manipulation and misdirection. Many today feel this lack of direction in symptoms ranging from constant, low-level anxiety to a desire to escape to a completely different life. It is no surprise that the lack of fulfillment in our collective lives on the Hedonic Treadmill has produced record levels of depression, obesity and personal bankruptcy.
Do Economic Sanctions Work?
Just this week the United States government was able to convince the UN Security Council increase economic sanctions on Iran over its nuclear program. As scary as a nuclear Iran can be, there's a lot of evidence that economic sanctions do not have that high a success rate. Here's a chart from a paper from the Peterson Institute for International Economics:
Even getting modest policy changes happen 51% of the time. This is important when you consider just how many nations the US currently has sanctions on. I'm not suggesting sanctions never work, clearly that's not the case. I am suggesting there is a better way, the opposite of sanctions, trade. As I've mentioned before, trading with other nations is more likely to make us allies. Compare our relationships with Cuba and China. The one we have opened trade with has Westernized their economy, and in some ways their culture, radically in the last 15 years. The other is still one of the few remaining completely communist nations. Bad for Americans (cigars and beaches) and bad for Cubans (poverty and tyranny). Sanctions inherently hurt the poor working citizen, where as the political elite, who are actually those we seek to impact, can easily weather financial hardship. You are unlikely to shame them into submission. In fact, economic sanctions may actually be increasing support for those you wish to exert pressure on.
Even getting modest policy changes happen 51% of the time. This is important when you consider just how many nations the US currently has sanctions on. I'm not suggesting sanctions never work, clearly that's not the case. I am suggesting there is a better way, the opposite of sanctions, trade. As I've mentioned before, trading with other nations is more likely to make us allies. Compare our relationships with Cuba and China. The one we have opened trade with has Westernized their economy, and in some ways their culture, radically in the last 15 years. The other is still one of the few remaining completely communist nations. Bad for Americans (cigars and beaches) and bad for Cubans (poverty and tyranny). Sanctions inherently hurt the poor working citizen, where as the political elite, who are actually those we seek to impact, can easily weather financial hardship. You are unlikely to shame them into submission. In fact, economic sanctions may actually be increasing support for those you wish to exert pressure on.
Thursday, June 10, 2010
Emptying the Bottle: Mid-June '10 Links
Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
- An atomic bomb could stop the Gulf oil leak [video].
- Massive sinkhole swallows city building [photo].
- Hyperlinks in embedded in printed books.
- EMDR helps clients address dysfunctionally stored memories (earlier).
- Save the ocean, libertarian style [video].
- Justification for my obsession with keeping every book I've ever read.
- Who gives the government millions of dollars in gifts to reduce the debt [graphic]?
- Trying to turn a Democrat into a libertarian.
- Testing a space suit: "I could feel the saliva on my tongue start to boil" [video].
- Your memory can't be trusted (earlier).
- Ambiguous political answers wins elections.
- Elton John sang at Rush Limbaugh's wedding and for rational reasons.
To follow live and to see comments, subscribe via Google Reader.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


.jpg)