Thursday, November 18, 2010

Pre-Paying Volunteers or Economists

About a month ago I got a letter in my box at school asking me to take a survey. It was from the Educational Research Associates. I hadn't heard of them, but on the web their name was regularly associated with "individualized instruction". The idea seems to be a push away from lecture oriented learning and towards alternative instructional methods (audio, video, computer-assisted instruction) freeing the teacher to focus on individuals needs. Though that idea seems very appealing to someone who uses the crude method of talking fast to get through the vast amount of information required for most subjects, it wasn't the most interesting part of the letter. This was:


That's the letter and one dollar. At the very bottom of the letter you can read why they attached a dollar. It was to encourage, or should I say guilt, me into taking the survey. Before I tell you whether I took it or not, let me share some research:
The students made 50 decisions about giving. In some cases students started with $10, and for each dollar they gave up, their (anonymous) partner in the game would get, say, $5. In this case, giving was "cheap." In others, giving was expensive (each dollar given up yielded only 20 cents for the partner).

Someone who gives a lot when it's cheap and keeps most of the pie for himself when giving is expensive focuses on efficiency: He's making sure the maximum amount is paid out to him and his partner combined. Someone who keeps 80% of the pie when it would be cheap to give is more focused on equality. Someone who always keeps everything, regardless of the price of giving, is just plain selfish, the very embodiment of the rational, self-interested Homo economicus.

It turns out that exposure to economics makes a big difference in how students split the pie, in terms of both efficiency and outright selfishness. Students assigned to classes taught by economists were more likely to give a lot when it was cheap to do so. But they were also much more likely to take the whole pie for themselves.
Here's some more:
A substantial body of research suggests that economists are less generous than other professionals and that economics students are less generous than other students. We address this question using administrative data on donations to social programs by students at the University of Washington. Our data set allows us to track student donations and economics training over time in order to distinguish selection effects from indoctrination effects. We find that economics majors are less likely to donate than other students and that there is an indoctrination effect for non-majors but not for majors.
There some evidence that this may be a selection effect, but I'm skeptical. Tim Harford does a decent job defending economists, but I'm not sure it will convince everyone. So back to the original question, what do you think, did the $1 bribe work? Or did I take the money and run? The latter. I didn't take the survey. Here's a couple reasons why: 1) I spent the money on "generous jeans Friday", which donates the money to needy students for graduation robes, field trip fees, etc. Perhaps that was enough to silence my conscience. 2) Maybe the bribe itself kept me from completing it. Like my previous post on paying donors to give blood, maybe the low price made me think my input wasn't that valuable. 3) Maybe I'm just not your normal teacher.  When I went to look at the site just now all I saw was this message:
Thank you for accessing the World Geography Survey. We have had an overwhelming response and the field time is now closed. We hope you will consider participating in the future.

Thank you for your interest.
Apparently the average teacher hasn't taken enough economics. Or maybe I've taken too much.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

I Fixed the Deficit!

Even though it seems most Americans don't care about the deficit, I've talked plenty about it. How our government's debt is the fault of every president of the last 80 years and how it  may be a small problem now, but could turn into a big problem if nothing is done. I mostly proposed more immigration and economic growth as the main ways to ensure fiscal stability. However, the New York Times recently created a Budget Puzzle interactive graphic that lets you cut or tax (you have to do both) what you'd like in order to balance the budget in 2015 and 2030. I tried it out and was surprised how easy it was.

The federal budget was balanced by only increasing the Social Security retirement and Medicare eligibility age to 68, reducing the tax break for employer-provided health insurance, capping Medicare growth starting in 2013, enact medical malpractice reform, cut troops in Iraq and Afghanistan in half by 2013, reduce the size of the other  military to pre-Iraq level, eliminating loopholes in the income tax, ending farm subsidies, measuring inflation more accurately, and returning the estate tax to Clinton-era levels (although I also cut foreign aid and eliminated earmarks just for the fun of it). I didn't even have to change the Bush tax-cuts or payroll tax. I even refrained from the personally preferred carbon tax. Here's a link to exactly what I did. Now go and try it yourself, especially if you're a member of Congress.

Economics of Advice

I've posted my most repeated advice and why taking advice can be so important. Even though we know we don't know everything, it's often hard to take advice. There's a way to fix that, pay for it. Here's the experiment:
Dozens of students were asked questions about American history and received small cash prizes for correct answers. The students were either given the option of receiving advice on the correct answers, or advice was imposed on them. Sometimes this advice was free; other times it was paid for out of the students' winnings. Crucially, the advice always came from the same source - in the form of the answer that a student from a pilot session had given to the same question - so the quality of advice was held constant regardless of whether it was free or paid for.

Throughout the study, the participants took more account of advice they had paid for than advice they were given free, even though it was made clear to them that the advice was of the same quality. A final study showed the students took even more account of advice if it was made more expensive.

Gino said her findings could be explained by a phenomenon in decision-making theory known as the sunk cost fallacy. This is our desire to justify our past investments through our present and future behaviour - it's why that expensive pair of shoes that you never wear is still cluttering up your cupboard. In the case of advice, it seems we feel compelled to use guidance we've paid for, so as to justify the expense. And perhaps it explains why expensive frauds can sometimes be so influential.
This explains why expensive therapy can be so helpful. Just so you know, I love getting specific questions from readers. Feel free to pay me for extra effect.

Monday, November 15, 2010

We Lost the Election

Some great lines from P.J. O’Rourke:
I think we lost the election on November 2. Every race was won by a politician. True, we elected some angry nuts. These are preferable to common politicians. Their anger provokes honesty, and their mental illness prevents honesty from being obscured by charm. (What a loss -Barney Frank would have been as an exemplar of the furious, insane left!) We also elected some amateur politicians. However, politics is like vivisection—disturbing as a career, alarming as a hobby. And we may have elected a few reluctant politicians. But not reluctant enough.

We will win an election when all the seats in the House and Senate and the chair behind the desk in the Oval Office and the whole bench of the Supreme Court are filled with people who wish they weren’t there.

In a free country government is a dull and onerous responsibility. It is a parent-teacher conference. The teacher is a pompous twit. Our child is a lazy pain in the ass. We undertake this social obligation with weary reluctance. And we only do it at all because the teacher (political authority) deserves cold stares, hard questions, and maybe firing, and the pupil (that portion of society which, alas, needs governing) deserves to be grounded without TV and have its Internet access screened and its allowance docked.

America’s elected and appointed officials ought to be longing to return to their personal lives and private interests. They should feel burdened by their powers, irked with their responsibilities, and embarrassed at their prominence in the public eye. When they say they want to spend more time with their families, they should mean it.
I'm not one to pine for the past, but that's one of the characteristics I most appreciated from our Founding Fathers, especially George Washington. So what's the author's solution to this problem? A random draft for politicians.

Sunday, November 14, 2010

Targeted Advertising to Speeders

I got a speeding ticket last Monday. One of those downhill speed traps that would catch any patriotic speeder. The officer assured me that if I show up for the court date they'll probably drop the charges. It seems the biggest bummer about the speeding tax is that eventually you'll have to pay it. Lucky for me I get an interesting blog post out it. It wasn't the ticket itself, but what happened afterward that was most interesting. By Saturday, just a couple of days later, I had this in my mailbox:


That's a dozen letters from local lawyers letting me know they could help in my case. Apparently my ticket is public information and this is the direct mail version of ambulance chasing. Best of all, most of the letters acknowledged the ridiculousness of the situation. One even stated that I should expect to receive up to twenty similar letters, but that if I wanted quality I should hire them. I think for now I'll go rogue and represent myself.

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Results from News Bias Survey

Whether it's MSNBC and Kieth Olbermann, NPR and Juan Williams, or CNN and Rick Sanchez, it seems journalists have come under a lot of fire lately. Not accounting for the importance of journalistic integrity, there is evidence that balanced arguments can actually be more persuasive. This is why last week I asked my readers to take a list of traditional news sources and rank them based on their perceived bias. Thanks to surveyor extraordinaire Justin Landwehr, here are the results organized in a nice graphic :

(Extreme Conservative, Conservative, Unbiased, Liberal, Extreme Liberal)














Though my sample size was only a dozen (you can read all the details here), the results were enlightening. The usual suspects fell where I expected with Fox News and the Wall Street Journal on the right and the Los Angeles Times and MSNBC on the left. What I wanted to see most was what sources were viewed as actually fair and balanced. Here it seems USA Today, BBC News, and the Washington Post win out. Most surprising to me was that I, the Bottlenecked Blog, was seen as one of the most conservative sources. Perhaps it's my appreciation for the free market or my regular mention of God. Either way I did not expect to be seen as so far right.

My takeaway from the survey is that bias is hard to avoid. This is certainly nothing new. Here's a great podcast I've shared before about the economics behind the rise of balanced journalism. This may be another one of the great benefits to blogging. Like op-eds for the everyman, they give us the opportunity to know and trust our sources of information. Thanks again to all who participated in the survey and to those who continue to support this little corner of the blogosphere.

English From Around the World

Last year I shared a video on what English sounds like to foreigners. Now for the opposite. The Speech Accent Archive recorded speech samples from people all over the world reading the same paragraph. At first I thought I would just use it to improve my characters on stage, but I've mostly been playing the "guess this place" game with my wife. Here's some to try out: Australia, China, Brazil, Sudan, and Texas.

Friday, November 12, 2010

Economics of Oprah's Book Club

Like any post on Oprah, this one is for my wife:
It is well known that celebrity endorsement can have a very significant impact on the sale of products, and nowhere is this more true than with the Oprah Winfrey book club. If Oprah endorses a book, not only club members buy it en masse, but also non-members who see the endorsement on television or in the New York Times. But the spill-over does not stop here.

Indeed, Eyal Carmi, Gal Oestreicher-Singer and Arun Sundararajan show that when potential buyers go to Amazon.com to make their purchase of their endorsed book, they are presented with recommendations, which they may also buy, and then get further recommendations. It turns out that these recommendations are followed quite a bit, which generates something like a network contagion effect. The authors find that over several days after the endorsement, such a contagion effect can be significant through five levels. I would have expected this to happen when an academic click through a literature by looking at a paper's references and citations, but I would not have expected this to be so important for laypeople purchasing books, especially within days.
That's from Economic Logic.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Problem with Veteran's Day, Another Controversial Belief

Two years ago I posted my most controversial belief: "that I don't support many seemingly innocent charitable causes". After a good (and long) conversation with my readers, I was convinced that private donations can be an important way the market accounts for passionate consumers. In light of Veteran's Day, and Penelope Trunk's own controversial post, I'd like to share another controversial belief of mine in the hopes that it will be refined again. I believe that the wrong kind of appreciation is paid to American soldiers.

Today the airwaves were full of patriotic stories praising our soldiers with hyperbolic statements that overshadowed the real commitment our soldiers have made. The reality is that the United States has not fought a defensive war since Japan bombed Pearl Harbor in 1941 (which happened because of U.S. exports to Allied forces). That means every military conflict since World War II have not been about for "protecting our freedom". Whether it's the Korean War, Vietnam War, our numerous conflict with South American nations or the intervention in the Middle East of the last two decades; almost every living U.S. Veteran is not responsible for the freedom I personally experience.

That doesn't mean they're not worthy of recognition. I've posted before on how supporting our troops doesn't imply believing "in the nobility of the mission". I've also posted about the importance of social rewards to most the valued members of our society. I'm not suggesting we ignore the brave soldiers of the U.S. military. What I do suggest is praising them for the important things they have accomplished. Like Great Britain before us and Rome before them, the United States military has increased global connectivity to the betterment of its people and the world. Not only have we been more successful at this important goal, we've done it with less coercion than our predecessors.

I'm the last person to suggest that all, or even most, American military action is acceptable. However, today I'd like our soldiers for the role they've played in American and global prosperity. Today I'd like to specifically thank my grandfather, my father, and my uncle for their past and present contribution.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Emptying the Bottle: Mid-November '10 Links

Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
As always, feel free to email me anything interesting you come across.