In a now infamous poll from Pew Research Center, 18% of Americans claimed that President Obama is a Muslim. As shocking as those numbers are, it's a good reminder of exactly what opinion polls are, opinions. More than that, they are non-expert opinions. Even more than that, they are non-expert opinions on issues that are mostly opinion. What is Obama's religion? Are in for a double-dip recession? How likely is another major terrorist attack? All of these questions are are pure speculation.
In a democracy, I can understand the desire to know the opinions of the people, but we aren't a democracy, we are a republic. This is an important distinction in understanding sensitive issues like religion or the recent controversy over gay marriage in California. For the purpose of law, it doesn't matter what a majority of Californians voted for, the government is restricted by the Constitution. The courts claimed that limiting marriage in this way violated the right to equal protection and due process. Now, whether those clauses were interpreted correctly is a different matter.
Another final reason why I'm weary of pollsters is how important the wording of question are. For issues like gay rights there are red flag words that can get desired results. For example most Americans oppose same-sex "marriage", but half support "civil unions". Depending on which word is used, results vary significantly. This not only shows bias in pollster agenda, but just how blurry many political lines are. Opinion polls may be valuable for politicians trying to understand their constituents, but voters shouldn't concern themselves with them.
Saturday, August 21, 2010
Friday, August 20, 2010
I Have Bad Taste in Entertainment
I like fast food. I like the music of Hanson. I like Zombie movies. I find myself frustrated with museums. I get bored by slow movies. And my favorite type of live performance is improv comedy. Though I certainly appreciate well made entertainment. I really enjoyed the National Museum of American History in DC. Shawshank Redemption ranks among my favorite movies. I even love the classic rock of The Rolling Stones. But when it comes down to what would I like to do with my spare time, it usually doesn't involve the classics. I say all that to gain the freedom that comes with admission. I have bad taste in entertainment. Now I'm off to finish watching the trailer for the new movie Monsters.
Thursday, August 19, 2010
Difference Between Humans and Animals, Part IX
Here's what chimpanzee researchers in Uganda have been observing:
Here's part one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, and eight of this continuing series.
A band of males, up to 20 or so, will assemble in single file and move to the edge of their territory. They fall into unusual silence as they penetrate deep into the area controlled by the neighboring group. They tensely scan the treetops and startle at every noise. “It’s quite clear that they are looking for individuals of the other community,”Here's why:
The objective of the 10-year campaign was clearly to capture territory, the researchers concluded. The Ngogo males could control more fruit trees, their females would have more to eat and so would reproduce faster, and the group would grow larger, stronger and more likely to survive.For a series on the differences between humans and animals, this certainly sounds eerily like human behavior. The article linked above even discusses the similarities between the chimpanzee conflict and warfare among human groups that still live by hunting and gathering. But that similarity actually reveals a huge difference. Most humans don't hunt and gather anymore. Almost all people today live within the collaborative international community. This is not a result of biological evolution, but cultural evolution. We have established clear property rights enforced by a social contract between billions of people. The last several decades have seen relatively unprecedented peace between groups. Something the animal kingdom cannot imagine.
Here's part one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, and eight of this continuing series.
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Emptying the Bottle: Mid-August '10 Links
Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
- What it looks like when economists try to lose weight.
- Practical suggestions for threatening situations.
- Voting in churches makes you more likely to vote conservatively.
- Dutch council helps jobless women find rich men to marry (earlier).
- Good advice for any presentation.
- Immigration and the protection racket.
- Why you should reveal more about yourself.
- Commuting is bad for your health (earlier).
- China is richer than... El Salvador.
- Good summary of the last 10 years.
Lessons from the German Economic Miracle
In a recent comment a reader proposed that the post-WWII Marshall Plan was a great example of government stimulus leading to national prosperity. Based on my previous posts on foreign aid, you might guess I don't agree with the common assumption. Economist David Henderson also disagrees and claims economic growth was mostly due to three other factors:
The two main factors were currency reform and the elimination of price controls, both of which happened over a period of weeks in 1948. A further factor was the reduction of marginal tax rates later in 1948 and in 1949.The article goes into a lot more detail, but here's his specific response to the Marshall Plan story:
Marshall Plan aid to West Germany was not that large. Cumulative aid from the Marshall Plan and other aid programs totaled only $2 billion through October 1954. Even in 1948 and 1949, when aid was at its peak, Marshall Plan aid was less than 5 percent of German national income. Other countries that received substantial Marshall Plan aid exhibited lower growth than Germany.
Tuesday, August 17, 2010
The Real Power of the Market
Often the phrase "the market" is described as a god-like entity by its supporters (of which I am probably guilty) and a false god by its opponents. The always interesting Tyler Cowen puts it best in his Big Think interview:
So I think for the most part, markets and capitalists’ wealth help people become more of what they are, that’s something, in most cases, entirely acceptable. There are exceptions. There are people who are psychotics. And in a market economy, they can buy a gun, whereas back in the Stone Age, they only had a club and that make society worse. That’s a case where markets, I wouldn’t say they corrupted the psychotic, but they help a corrupted person be more destructive, but if you look at the world as a whole, do you see more production or do you see more destruction in market economies? I think it’s pretty clear what the answer is. You see a lot more production, you see a lot more cooperation, you see a lot more people striving after noble ends even if it’s just for their own happiness and the happiness of their families.How does the market do it? Through the organization of its components, primarily human beings. This inherent market structure is shown in this video posted by the other writer of Marginal Revolution, Alex Tabarrok:
Monday, August 16, 2010
The Economic Stimulus Package, Last Part
Two years ago I posted on why I didn't think the stimulus package would work, why I didn't think the very very first worked, and why I might consider it as a "temporal progressive tax". But since the Federal Reserve recently predicted the recovery is slowing down, it's worth one last look. In this NPR podcast (via Justin) one of my favorite economists Tyler Cowen puts it like this: there has never been a very good test of Keynesian stimulus and in fact, this last stimulus package has probably the best chance to test it. A year and half ago he predicted it wouldn't help, and that it wasn't worth the risk to spend a trillion dollars on an untested idea.
But here's the worst part, because the macro-economy is so large and so unwieldy, even though this stimulus hasn't ended the recession in the predicted amount of time, it proves nothing. Supporters can reasonably say it would have been worse without it. Although I can't say with completely certainty the stimulus package has done more harm than good, the opposite can't be proven either. And it seems the burden of proof should be on the party wanting to spend a billion dollars.
But here's the worst part, because the macro-economy is so large and so unwieldy, even though this stimulus hasn't ended the recession in the predicted amount of time, it proves nothing. Supporters can reasonably say it would have been worse without it. Although I can't say with completely certainty the stimulus package has done more harm than good, the opposite can't be proven either. And it seems the burden of proof should be on the party wanting to spend a billion dollars.
Sunday, August 15, 2010
Saturday, August 14, 2010
Healthy Healthy Relationships
I've mentioned before how I think resolved conflict and dedication lead to rich relationships. But here's some evidence on the health benefits to them:
The benefit of friends, family and even colleagues turns out to be just as good for long-term survival as giving up a 15-cigarette-a-day smoking habit. And by the study's numbers, interpersonal social networks are more crucial to physical health than exercising or beating obesity.Here's why:
Social relationships are thought to help improve health either by buffering individuals from stressful situations or creating a norm of healthful behaviors.It seems the more healthy relationships you can foster, the better off you are (barring passion fatigue). So skip the gym today and go grab a smoke with a friend. And it's worth noting, although therapy is helpful, it isn't a replacement for real relationship.
"There's a pretty large literature linking social relationships to a variety of physiological processes that are linked to disease risk," Holt-Lunstad says. Social support has been linked to lower blood pressure, and a diverse collection of contacts is associated with better immune system functioning.
Friday, August 13, 2010
Role of the Church in the State
Christianity, with over 2 billion adherents, is the largest religion in the world. It is also the fastest growing. Thanks mostly to Africa and Asia, there 25 million believers added each year. Yet in academic circles, religion is often relegated to the background or worse, ignored as myth and fairytale. Religion's importance is hard to ignore, but its role in a diverse democracy is even harder to understand.
For centuries Europe, one of the few places Christianity is shrinking, has decided to combine church and state, with devastating results (Crusades, Spanish Inquisition, etc). But even today, the strong ties of European governments and their preferred religion have hurt both church and state. The British government, although it gives no direct funds to the Church of England, is much closer than most Americans would be comfortable with. For example, the Church of England gets 26 unelected members in the House of Lords (like our Senate). More recently, the United Kingdom's Big Society plan, though appealing in some ways, could tie the two financially even tighter.
Religious freedom, perhaps one of the United States' greatest exports, has allowed for a flourishing religious and secular society. Political institutions should not hinder or support Christianity (or any religion), because Christians have different perspectives on politics. So what is the role of the church in the state? In a lecture to to U.C. Berkley, Pastor Tim Keller (earlier) describes the role of the church as one that "shows us what human flourishing looks like", then we let the political debate begin.
For centuries Europe, one of the few places Christianity is shrinking, has decided to combine church and state, with devastating results (Crusades, Spanish Inquisition, etc). But even today, the strong ties of European governments and their preferred religion have hurt both church and state. The British government, although it gives no direct funds to the Church of England, is much closer than most Americans would be comfortable with. For example, the Church of England gets 26 unelected members in the House of Lords (like our Senate). More recently, the United Kingdom's Big Society plan, though appealing in some ways, could tie the two financially even tighter.
Religious freedom, perhaps one of the United States' greatest exports, has allowed for a flourishing religious and secular society. Political institutions should not hinder or support Christianity (or any religion), because Christians have different perspectives on politics. So what is the role of the church in the state? In a lecture to to U.C. Berkley, Pastor Tim Keller (earlier) describes the role of the church as one that "shows us what human flourishing looks like", then we let the political debate begin.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
.jpg)