Thursday, October 07, 2010

God Allows for Inefficiency

I recently came across these verses in Deuteronomy 15:1-3:
1 At the end of every seven years you must cancel debts. 2 This is how it is to be done: Every creditor shall cancel the loan he has made to his fellow Israelite. He shall not require payment from his fellow Israelite or brother, because the LORD's time for canceling debts has been proclaimed. 3 You may require payment from a foreigner, but you must cancel any debt your brother owes you.
As you might have predicted, it caused some problems:
Seeing that the law which prescribed the release of all debts every seventh year brought about the harmful consequence that people refused to loan to one another and thus violated what was written in the Law, namely, that a money loan should not be withheld because of the approach of the Sabbatical year
A deadweight loss, that is a loss to society, was created. It hurt lenders and it hurt borrowers. This was no surprise to God. Here are verses 7-9:
7 If there is a poor man among your brothers in any of the towns of the land that the LORD your God is giving you, do not be hardhearted or tightfisted toward your poor brother. 8 Rather be openhanded and freely lend him whatever he needs. 9 Be careful not to harbor this wicked thought: "The seventh year, the year for canceling debts, is near," so that you do not show ill will toward your needy brother and give him nothing.
Although the problem was predicted and offered a solution (be generous), the problem still occurred. So much so that Jewish culture created the compromise of an interest-free loan in the seventh year. I'm not sure where I stand on the issue. It is certainly something created specifically for the Jewish people's interaction with each other (with the emphasis on "brother" in verse 3). Either way, I think there is a characteristic of God that cannot be missed: He was willing to created inefficiencies in the market to strengthen cultural and relational bonds. And since he is unchanging, he still is.

Wednesday, October 06, 2010

The Wire Never Ends

Last night my wife and I finished HBO's Baltimore based television drama, The Wire. It is, without a doubt, the best show I have ever seen. Created by Baltimore native and former newspaper reporter, David Simon, the story unfolds in five different seasons, each with their own focus. Starting with the street drug trade, it moved into the city ports, then the Baltimore government, then into the school system, and ending with the local newspaper industry. I was simultaneously frustrated and charmed by a city I've never even visited. It made me wish David Simon would make a show about the city I grew up in.

The series ties the riveting plot, dynamic characters, and poignant themes together with a metaphorical "wire" constantly revealing truth through fiction. It shows the destruction of the drug war on American streets. It shows young street kids full of hope turned into dealers, users, and killers. The trade off borne after September 11th when the federal government began focusing more of its attention on terrorism. Without giving too much away, one of the few success stories doesn't come from one of the featured institutions, but instead when a struggling "corner kid" is adopted into a functional middle-class family. It shows the great ingenuity of humanity and how that can be used for corruption and destruction.

The show never feared taking risks. It used former drug dealers, addicts, and murders as actors. The drug dealing entrepreneur Stringer Bells takes economics classes in night school. And it uses a murdering, thieving, homosexual, stick-up man as the voice of morality. I don't mind revealing these small spoilers because it truly wasn't the destination, but the journey that makes this show. Not just a good televion show, but a visual novel. It impacted how I think about drug laws, political corruption, and my own role as a teacher in the classroom. Even the theme music, which uses the same lyrics reconstructed into different genres for every season, gives it a bookend feeling.

Finally, the series closing montage shows us that the The Wire, or the ideas presented in the show never end. "The game", legal and illegal, continues as new characters replace old, often dead, ones. Though the mini-series to which the show is based, The Corner (and the book before that), won an emmy, the show was never recognized with awards or overwhelming viewers. Journalist Joe Klein puts it best on the DVD extras: "The Wire never won an Emmy? The Wire should win the Nobel Prize for literature!” However, it did recently win a $500,000 "genius grant" from the MacArthur Foundation. If you haven't yet had the privilege, take the time and enjoy the series. You will not be disappointed.

Tuesday, October 05, 2010

Emptying the Bottle: Early-October '10 Links

Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
To follow live and to see comments, subscribe via Google Reader.

Monday, October 04, 2010

Takeaways from Predictably Irrational, Part IV

I recently finished Dan Ariely's Predictably Irrational. You can read Dan's current writing at his blog. Here is part one, part two, and part three in a multi-part series of my takeaways from the book. Here is the next and final part, focusing mostly on irrationality in our morals:

Economics is a lot like physics, if particles could think.

There are two types of dishonesty: malice and under the rug. The latter represents a much larger percentage than the first. When cheating is possible, it's not that a few that cheat a lot. It's most people will cheat a little.

Robberies in the US totaled $508 million in losses. Burglary offenses suffered $4.6 billion in lost property. Employee theft from small businesses in America equals $40 billion!

For most people, cheating isn't based on whether you will get caught, but based on whether you can justify it (at least for upper middle class college students).

Reminding people of their morals, for example having them write the Ten Commandments, greatly increases their chances of acting morally. I used this recently in the classroom when I gave my AP Micro students a take home test and made them sign an oath not to work together.

Honesty and trustworthiness are an important factors for wealth creation. It is costly to prevent immorality.

Surprisingly, the presence of cash decreases cheating. People are more likely to cheat when money is not involved. For example if you left a wallet with dollars in it in a break room few people will steal. But if you put sodas in a fridge they will get taken. One way to combat the theft of stuff is to put a price tag on it.

Non-cash cheating is an increasing problem was we move away from cash dealings. Think credit card fraud, trading online, or credit default swaps.

Like the take home test oath, clear contracts can help prevent fraud. Cash even looks like a tiny contract. In person deals can also prevent cheating. In fact, even putting a picture of human eyes nearby can decrease theft. Is this why we put pictures of trusted leaders on our dollars?

Improving our rationality can create "free lunches" by improving our decision making. This is one of the best practical applications for economics.

My summary of the book: Thinking has a cost, so we find shortcuts. Those shortcuts aren't full proof. So these are actually rational responses to the costs of mental calculations and moral reasoning. This can be helpful to people by making the "best" decision easier to make (by pre-committing to retirement savings). It can also be helpful to businesses by making the most profitable decision easier to make (example from the Economist). The way to avoid irrational habits is to constantly reevaluate what you do and why you do it. However, the benefits of getting it right may not be worth the cost of figuring it out. "The unexamined life is not worth living", but perhaps the overly examined isn't either.

Although I loved the book, I'm not convinced people are Predictably Irrational. Instead, I think they are Rationally Irrational.

Sunday, October 03, 2010

Possible Solution to American Prison Crisis

The United States puts more of its citizens behind bars than any other country in the world. Over two million Americans, or about one out of a hundred adults, are currently in prison at a cost of $50,000 per inmate per year. Those behind bars are overwhelmingly poor and overwhelmingly black. One of the saddest results of this is that one in twenty-eight children are missing a parent (mostly for non-violent crimes) because of arrest. And the numbers are only getting worse. With more than a fifth of incarcerations for drug offenses, the most obvious solution is to decriminalize drugs. But I understand most Americans, even liberals and especially conservatives, don't want that. However, a more practical solution may already be in use. As many people as we have in prison, we have even more under "correctional supervision".

In a great article from The Atlantic, the idea of a "prison without walls" is discussed. Instead of putting citizens behind bars, keep them under close surveillance, mostly using GPS ankle bracelets. This is cheaper for taxpaying families and the families of inmates. The most extreme would of course remain locked up, but the majority of offenders could be rehabilitated where it really counts, in society. They can help nudge those that need it the most. One company in Indianapolis is already preventing sex offenders from getting near schools, drunk drivers from getting near bars, and general trouble makers in their home at night. Hawaii is also trying a this kind of long-distance babysitting with similar success.

As uncomfortable as Big Brother tracking its citizens is to me, it's better than locking them away. The sad reality is that putting criminals in a den of criminals will rarely help them avoid the mistakes that got them there. Something needs to change. I think this may be one step in the right direction.

Friday, October 01, 2010

Takeaways from Predictably Irrational, Part III

I recently finished Dan Ariely's Predictably Irrational. You can read Dan's current writing at his blog. Here is part one and part two in a multi-part series of my takeaways from the book. Here is the next part, focusing mostly on where irrationality comes from:

This book is one sentence is an economist looking through the lens of psychology.

When men are sexually aroused there are about twice as likely to admit to interest in what they would deem as morally reprehensible. My guess is there is a similar correlation between other intense emotions like anger, jealousy, sadness, excitement, etc.

These moments of irrationality seem to be evidence to support Biblical truths about fleeing from sin. Avoiding temptation is easier than overcoming it.

There seem to be trade offs between reason and emotion. Like Jekyll and Hyde, each side has it's own strengths. In 2010 America, the calm collected Dr. Jekyll is preferred.

Often there are ways to predict how we might act when emotion arises. Another example from the book is for women deciding whether to pre-plan for an epidural during childbirth. She should attempt putting her hand in freezing water for 2 minutes. Amidst the pain she can predict what she'll want when the pain of birthing begins.

There are also steps we can take to put ourselves a step or two removed from making emotionally driven bad decisions. One unique example from the book is putting your credit card in the freezer in a cup of frozen water.

Predict their savings rates: USA, Europe, Japan, China. Approximate answers (in order): 0%, 20%, 25%, 50%.

The endowment effect is a well documented theory that people value something more after they own it (related to the aforementioned loss aversion). This can lead to a couple different problems: 1) fall in love with what we have to the detriment of what we could have, 2) expect others to value it just as much. So should we  buy less things? Sell less things?

Advertisements play off this owning effect through "virtual ownership".

Another problem associated with this is people don't like giving up potential options. Like the story of Buridan's ass, not making a choice is often the worst choice. Here's an article on the main experimental example in the book. Here's my earlier post on too much choice.

This helps describe the problems of constant career changers, over-activities kids, and people with too many hobbies. In fact, it challenged me, someone who spends a significant amount of time blogging and improvising.

This endowing effect also effects what we believe? It's why first impressions are so important. If you have something bad to reveal, pre-load it with good news. Here's an example: beautiful catering trays with fancy food labels.

Another real world example is prejudice and stereotypes. Surprisingly, it impacts prejudice on those being stereotyped. For example Asians are viewed as good at math, women generally said to be worse at math. In an experiment Asian women were asked to take a math test. Half were initially asked questions about being a woman and they did worse on the test. The other half were asked questions about being Asian and they did better on the test.

A final example from the real world is the placebo effect. I've discussed how perhaps education and ignorance can be placebos, but I'd never considered the reverse placebo effect. If something is perceived as low quality (often measured in price), it may not have it's highest possible effect. Perhaps this may be one of the trade offs in our attempt to decrease health care costs.

I'm unsure how this should impact the pricing of an improv show. Does an expensive show signal quality and therefore increase the average enjoyment of the show? Going back to the first takeaways on the word free, which would get better ratings from an audience, a $12 show or a free show?

This unconscious effect of placebos can be counteracted by the acknowledgement of them.

A related Einstein quote: “Any intelligent fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius — and a lot of courage — to move in the opposite direction.”

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Selfish Reasons for Immigration

This may have replaced drug legalization as my issue of most interest. You've heard the moral, historic, and economic reasons for and the honest concerns against increasing US immigration. Now here are some selfish reasons for it:
Immigrants will solve our housing crisis. One major reason why housing prices remain in the doldrums and sales remain slack is that there are simply too many houses for sale. The National Association of Realtors reported that in July, there were 3.98 million existing homes on the market, representing a 12.5-month supply at the current pace of sales.
Here's another:
Immigrants are needed to replenish the American workforce. While the American labor force continues to grow, the rate at which it grows has been slowing down for decades. The Bureau of Labor Services projects that by 2020, the growth rate will be just 0.4 percent per year, and by 2030 just 0.3 percent per year. Some of this is attributable to baby boomers moving into retirement homes, and some is attributable to declining birth rates.
And one more:
Immigrants make the economy better. Not only does the San Francisco Fed paper—written, appropriately, by an Italian economist, Giovanni Peri—argue that immigrants don't hurt the economy, it actually makes the case that immigrants are putting money in the pockets of native-born workers. Specifically, it says that "total immigration to the United States from 1990 to 2007 was associated with a 6.6 percent to 9.9 percent increase in real income per worker."
All of those talking about the need for a second stimulus should take my intro economics class. The best way to increase demand is to increase the number of demanders.

Related: In France at least, an increase in immigrants does not mean an increase in crime.

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Takeaways from Predictably Irrational, Part II

I recently finished Dan Ariely's behavioral economics book, Predictably Irrational. You can read Dan's current writing at his blog. Here is part one in a multi-part series of my takeaways from the book. Here is the next part, focusing mostly on the different kinds of exchanges:

There are two worlds of interaction, the world of social norms and the world of market norms. An example of social norm is a friend helping a friend move a couch. Market norm would be hiring a professional mover.

There can be unexpected problems s in the world of market norms. It was the famous efficiency expert Frederick Taylor who said there is "hardly a competent workman can be found who does not devote a considerable amount of time to studying just how slowly he can work and still convince his employer that he is going at a good pace."

In fact, social norms can actually be more productive. There's a famous story (couldn't find a link) about an attempt to increase the amount of blood donation by paying givers. Surprisingly, less blood was donated. The good feelings that came with donating were replaced by a payment too low to compensate for the lost feelings.

The market and social worlds have a hard time existing together, because when combined the normal pattern of interaction become unclear. Remember my earlier post on loaning friends money? The example in the book was a story about a day care that charged a fine for parents for late pickups and actually got more late pickups (because people didn't feel guilty anymore). After they removed the charge, the late pickups increased even more (because people still didn't feel guilty and now didn't have to pay). Here's my earlier post on moral math.

However, gifts (not cash) can be a way to use market incentives within a social norm would. That's why blood donors get t-shirts and cookies. But be sure not to mention how much the goodies cost.

Another problem with market norms is they make you feel more self-reliant. Think about how helpful you are at home without pay, but how favors at work are bothersome. You assume other people are just as self-reliant as you making you less willing to help others.

This helps explain why businesses want to harness the power of social norms. It's why State Farm is a "good neighbor" and Johnson & Johnson is "the family company". It also helps explain why companies originally gave sick days, health insurance, and other employee perks. They are trying to make you loyal to them. The only problem is they expect you to treat them with the same loyalty. If you nickel and dime employees/customers after you've made them feel like family they treat you not like a greedy corporation, but a like a deceptive uncle.

These social norms are also important for the most valued members of our society. It would be expensive to pay people to run into burning buildings. Or to take down and armed mugger. Or to go to war. Yet firefighters, policemen, and soldiers are plentiful. It's not just because we pay them with money, but because we pay them with respect. They get parades, discounts, and drinks bought for them at bars.

I've always been skeptical of what Dan Ariely calls social norms in the marketplace, but this book showed me their value.

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Preference Bidding

In any relationship there is always give and take. Some more than others. To form a lasting friendship you must be willing to do things you don't want to because it pleases the person you care about. Whether it's washing dishes or forfeiting your vote for a movie choice, resolving conflict is important for intimacy. However, when sacrifice is needed, who should make it? If we care about efficiency, which we do, then costs should be minimized. My brother-in-law, who recently wrote a guest post, once told me he and his wife would rank, one to ten, how much cared about the decision. The person with the larger number got their way. The only problem with this system is that the incentive to strategically inflate my preference, even unknowingly, is too strong. Instead, I suggest something more technical, a preference bid.

In a preference bid (my terminology) each side will make an offer of a favor to the other in exchange for getting their way. I'll let you pick the movie, if you buy the popcorn. I'll wash dishes, if you take out the trash. And so on. This will ensure they are backing up what they say. This is done all the time. Unless of course, you combine the two ideas I've mentioned. Instead of letting your friend rank how much they care with a unprovable number, offer them a favor exchange. Be sure to offer something that would signal they care more than you. If they accept, then go with their preference. Now here's the twist. Don't actually make them do what they agreed to. It wasn't about exchanging favors, it was about determining how much they cared. Now you know, so there is no reason to go any further.

In repeated games there may be an incentive to cheat, now knowing they won't actually have to do what they offered. To prevent this you could randomly make them do the favor offered. By say calling a coin flip or rolling a die and seeing if it lands on the month they were born. That should be enough for them to bid properly, but not actually have to do you favors (which like money exchanges could ruin friendships). The other obvious option is to always sacrifice your own preferences for those you care about. My concern is that passion fatigue may actually ruin a relationships more than not getting your way. Perhaps a balance of the two is ideal.