Saturday, April 17, 2010

More Choice is Good, Usually

A key concept to economic libertarianism is that more choice is always welfare improving. If offered a choice between three jobs, you would choose the one that best suits. If suddenly you were offered seven more jobs, that could only lead to an improvement (because if the new offers weren't better, you'd stick with the original choice). Admittedly there are costs to making choices. This is described well by Barry Schwartz's Ted talk on The Paradox of Choice. This problem mostly exists when our subconscious emotional reason misleads us. A great example of this is a study about the increasing choices we having in dating. Their conclusion is that when faced with abundant choice, people pay less attention to hard to measure qualities and more attention to obvious characteristics. Increased choice means quicker decisions on who to date. Sadly that mean attractiveness trumps character and as I'm sure you know, the two are not correlated. Now that you know, try and compensate.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Another Benefit of Improvisation, Mirroring

One of the basic tools of creating improv scenes is mirroring. This is where one actor copies another actor in voice, rhythm, posture, etc. It's useful for creating an instantaneous connection between characters. The skill is also important in creating friendship in the real world:
Affiliation ratings were compared for an experimenter who either (a) tapped to a metronome that was synchronous to the participant's metronome, (b) tapped to a metronome that was asynchronous, or (c) did not tap. As hypothesized, in both studies, the degree of synchrony predicted subsequent affiliation ratings. Experiment 3 found that the affiliative effects were unique to interpersonal synchrony.
It can even make you more caring in general:
This suggests that mimicry created an affective empathic mindset, which activated prosocial behaviors directed toward others.
Speaking of mirroring, I'm pulling a double header at the improv theater tonight, at both 8pm and 9:30pm (free). Here are my two previous posts on the practical benefits of improvisation.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

For College, Don't Give Into Peer Pressure

As an teacher I try to be realistic about the benefits of education. I've mentioned the possibility that education is a placebo, but also shown the non-economic benefits of a college degree. I've even discussed why I'm glad I got B's in college. But there are certain students who can benefit from a good education, those who normally wouldn't:
A new study finds that the students who are least likely to go to college (based on family background, abilities, and friend group) are the ones with the most to gain from a degree. Jennie E. Brand and Yu Xie find that the unlikeliest male college graduates earned 30% more over their lifetimes than comparable men who earned only a high school degree. In contrast, male college graduates most likely to go to college earned only 10% more than their non-college-educated counterparts.
Related: my earlier attempt at a cartoon about peer pressure.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

The Elderly Economy

Here is quite a "sentence to ponder" from Tyler Cowen:
Of all the people in human history who ever reached the age of 65, half are alive now.
Here's the explanation:
The revolution has two aspects. First, we are not producing babies like we used to. In just a generation, world fertility has halved to just 2.6 babies per woman. In most of Europe and much of east Asia, fertility is closer to one child per woman than two, way below long-term replacement levels. The notion that the populations of places such as Brazil and India will go on expanding looks misplaced: in fact, they could soon be contracting.
It goes on to explain that traditional pensions and social security schemes where young workers support old workers will not survive. Here's a bit of historical perspective:
The idea of a retirement age was invented by Otto von Bismarck in the 1880s, when as chancellor of Germany he needed a starting age for paying war pensions. He chose the age of 65 because that was typically when ex-soldiers died.
Retirement will be pushed back. Under the current state teacher pension system I can retire at 51. That's 5 years as a child, 17 years of education for 28 years of work so I can "rest" for 25 years (at least, my grandpa is over 90). This is bankrupting both governments and private businesses that try to use it. Overall this isn't bad news, we are healthier at 70 than our ancestors ever were. We shouldn't be afraid, but we should be willing to change.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Value of Support

About two years ago, I wrote a post entitled: What is your most controversial belief? My answer was that I didn't support many seemingly worthy causes, namely giving to cancer research. I felt that charitable donations skewed the cost and benefit analysis done by profit seeking research firms. Thanks to loyal commenters I was convinced that caring friends and family affected by various diseases rationally subsidize such research, thereby improving overall welfare. Earlier this year I posted again to better explain why such donation drives had bothered me. I presented some research that showed by simply asking someone to donate to charity, you actually cost (in the economic sense) them up to $3.50.

Recently, I have been reminded of these issues, but in a more personal and less economic way. An old roommate and good friend of my wife's was recently diagnosed with Type 1 Diabetes, which can be fatal unless treated regularly with insulin shots. Her story is simultaneously tragic and hopeful. To channel her frustrations, she and her husband have committed themselves to participating in a 72 mile bike ride around Lake Tahoe which requires that they raise $8,000 for Diabetes research. My wife and I wanted to support them to bring the the world marginally closer to a cure, but mostly because we love them and wanted to encourage them, which is worth a lot (even in the economic sense).

Monday, April 12, 2010

Cost of Commuting

In a world with many choices, I admit sometimes we don't make the right ones. What I have a harder time understanding is repeated bad decisions. However I am not exempt from these seemingly irrational choices. I mentioned before how much I drive, but Jonah Lehrer suggests I don't:
According to the calculations of Frey and Stutzer, a person with a one-hour commute has to earn 40 percent more money to be as satisfied with life as someone who walks to the office.
Why is it so bad?
One reason is that it's a painful ritual we never get used to - the flow of traffic is inherently unpredictable. As a result, we don't habituate to the suffering of rush hour. (Ironically, if traffic was always bad, and not just usually bad, it would be easier to deal with. So the commutes that really kill us are those rare days when the highways are clear.) As the Harvard psychologist Daniel Gilbert notes, "Driving in traffic is a different kind of hell every day."
So why do 3.5 million Americans drive over three hours to and from work?
Consider two housing options: a three bedroom apartment that is located in the middle of a city, with a ten minute commute time, or a five bedroom McMansion on the urban outskirts, with a forty-five minute commute. "People will think about this trade-off for a long time," Dijksterhuis says. "And most them will eventually choose the large house. After all, a third bathroom or extra bedroom is very important for when grandma and grandpa come over for Christmas, whereas driving two hours each day is really not that bad." What's interesting, Dijksterhuis says, is that the more time people spend deliberating, the more important that extra space becomes. They'll imagine all sorts of scenarios (a big birthday party, Thanksgiving dinner, another child) that will turn the suburban house into an absolute necessity. The pain of a lengthy commute, meanwhile, will seem less and less significant, at least when compared to the allure of an extra bathroom. But, as Dijksterhuis points out, that reasoning process is exactly backwards: "The additional bathroom is a completely superfluous asset for at least 362 or 363 days each year, whereas a long commute does become a burden after a while."
I've been thinking about my commute for a long time. I'm right in the middle of my church, work, and improv theater, so for now it's definitely worth it. At least I have the benefits of renting and the flexibility to move in the cost minimizing direction.

Sunday, April 11, 2010

Difference Between Humans and Animals, Part V

One of the characteristics that seem uniquely human is being self-aware. Animals realize they exist, but it appears humans are able to do it on a much deeper level. One way to test this is through suicide. Only an animal that self evaluates will calculate whether life is worth living. So, do animals commit suicide? Not really:
If you mean, "Other than humans, do otherwise healthy and reproductively-capable individuals of any other species perform actions foreseeably guaranteed to result in their immediate death?", the answer is NO. Violate any one of the conditions in the preceding statement, and the answer is YES. Sick or injured animals of many different types will act in such ways as to guarantee a speedier end to their suffering, and this appears to include whale beachings. Whale beachings are also one reason for the qualifier "foreseeable," in that it appears healthy whales may follow a sick leader when the latter beaches--as social animals, they instinctively trust their leader, which under most circumstances would not lead them to their doom, so their unexpected (to them) beaching cannot be considered genuinely suicidal. For that matter, a rabbit that walks out into an open field when there's a hungry owl nearby may be performing an action virtually guaranteed to result in death--but not foreseeably so. Nor would an animal that dies defending its young necessarily be considered suicidal, even if the enemy is something pretty much impossible to defeat; after all, the enemy might retreat if it doesn't seem worth the trouble, so sometimes defense works.
Here's Part I, II, III, and IV.

Saturday, April 10, 2010

Emptying the Bottle: Mid-April '10 Links

Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
To follow my shared items live, subscribe.

Government Intrusion vs. Private Restriction

As I'm sure you've noticed, I don't like it when government steps in between producers and consumers. Often people get this mixed up with a dislike of businesses telling their buyers what to do. A good example of the difference is frustration with restaurants forcing a dress code:
armed with the swift feedback of market forces, does what governments tend to find rather difficult: balance the competing interests of different people. Some people will pay to eat a meal surrounded by the smart set. Other people will pay to eat a meal without having to dress up. The restaurateur gets to decide whose wishes count – the snobs or the slobs.
Government regulation is far from an entrepreneur who provides a specific type of restaurant. For me this makes the issue of smoking in bars clearer. However, it makes the issue of racial integration more muddled.

Friday, April 09, 2010

Why Economists Outweigh Historians

Teaching history has given me an appreciation for the importance of historical study. Yet we hear very little about historians in everyday life. Here's a pretty good explanation:
One answer I offered was that economists had managed a remarkable balancing act between making the guts of their work totally incomprehensible — and thus forbiddingly impressive — to the outside world while continuing to offer reasonably straightforward conclusions. The basic form of an academic economics paper is a couple of comprehensible paragraphs at the beginning and a couple of comprehensible paragraphs at the end, with a bunch of really-hard-to-follow math or statistical analysis in the middle. An academic history paper, on the other hand, is often an uninterrupted cascade of semi-comprehensible jargon that neither impresses a lay reader nor offers any clear conclusions.

The one economist in the audience had another suggestion. Most economic work was aimed at prediction, and the world is always hungry for predictions.He added that most macroeconomic predictions are worthless (he was a microeconomist), but that doesn't seem to have damped the demand for them.
Hopefully this recession has shown us the promises and limitations of economics.