Tuesday, November 09, 2010

Remember, Remember the 9th of November

I got the chance this weekend to watch one of my favorite movies, V for Vendetta. It's got all the action and thrill I love along with a strong libertarian message I can't resist. This weekend also marks the 405th anniversary of the Gunpowder Plot to which the entire movie/comic is loosely based. The movie's famous poem calls the people of London  to remember what V does on the 5th of November, but I think the focus should be on what happens the days following.

Now that the election results are in I can't help but appreciate the outcome. Not because Republicans won. Not even because of my appreciation for divided government. I like that the election restored fear, not to the people, to the government. I got a chance to attend the Daily Show rally in D.C. a couple of weeks ago and got to see hundreds of thousands of Americans rally for sanity (and comedy). I won't go into the rally itself, but here and here are two great takeaways from friends.

I will however compare Stewart's desire for sanity with the call to action in V for Vendetta. The terrorist V commits acts of violence to create fear, but unlike Colbert's push to "keep fear alive" for citizens, V wants to keep "governments afraid of their people". That is what I saw in the midterm election speeches. The great success of the Tea Party isn't that they helped the conservative movement, that isn't clear, but they they reminded politicians that they are held accountable by the voters. It isn't the election days that matter, it's the days that follow that determine our future.

Monday, November 08, 2010

Stossel and O'Reilly's Bet on Pot

Economics of "Economics of"

In the three years I've been blogging, I've done over 50 "economics of" posts. What's the value in trying to use economics to explain everything? I've mentioned before that libertarianism is tied to political knowledge. And apparently, the ability to "think like an economist" is tied to intelligence. First let's clarify how economists think:
they're more likely to be optimistic about the economy; to recognise the economic advantages of markets free from government interference, and the advantages of foreign trade and foreign workers; and to appreciate the economic benefits of achieving greater productivity with less man-power.
Here's the results of the study from Bryan Caplan:
Prior research has established that the more time a person spends in education, the more likely their broad economic views are to match that of the typical economist (pdf). Caplan and his colleague Stephen Miller point out that these studies failed to take into account the influence of intelligence. After all, it's known that people with higher IQ tend to spend longer in education and intelligence itself may also directly influence economic beliefs.

To overome this problem, Caplan and Miller have focused on answers to the General Social Survey, a massive US poll of national opinions performed every two years. Crucially, it includes questions about the economy and a small test of verbal IQ.

Caplan and Miller's finding is that the link between educational background and 'thinking like an economist' is weakened when IQ is taken into account because IQ is the more important factor associated with economic beliefs.
Hat tip to best of "economics of", Freakonomics.

Sunday, November 07, 2010

Yet Another Look at Government Stimulus

I know I've belabored this issue to death, but with the costs so large I think it's worth at least one more look. Over two and a half years ago I first predicted that the stimulus packages would not work. Later I posted that the stimuluses probably didn't work in the past (especially the New Deal) and that at best we'll never know if the cost was worth it. I eventually concluded that stimulus as a temporal tax progressive tax is the best and least used argument in favor.

The most famous example of government stimulus is World War II. And it with Ben Bernanke's recent announcement to print an extra $600 billion in a process called quantitative easing (aka increase the money supply), it seems the Federal Reserve's faith in government stimulus has not waned. However, a recent paper published by David Henderson suggest that World War II is a great study on stimulus, except that it proves the opposite of what you might think. First, here's the traditional thought process:
We often hear that big cuts in government spending over a short time are a bad idea. The case against big cuts, typically made by Keynesian economists, is twofold. First, large cuts in government spending, with no offsetting tax cuts, would lead to a large drop in aggregate demand for goods and services, thus causing a recession or even a depression. Second, with a major shift in demand (fewer government goods and services and more private ones), the economy will experience a wrenching readjustment, during which people will be unemployed and the economy will slow.
Now's here's the reality:
Yet, this scenario has already occurred in the United States, and the result was an astonishing boom. In the four years from peak World War II spending in 1944 to 1948, the U.S. government cut spending by $72 billion—a 75-percent reduction. It brought federal spending down from a peak of 44 percent of gross national product (GNP) in 1944 to only 8.9 percent in 1948, a drop of over 35 percentage points of GNP.

While government spending fell like a stone, federal tax revenues fell only a little, from a peak of $44.4 billion in 1945 to $39.7 billion in 1947 and $41.4 billion in 1948. In other words, from peak to trough, tax revenues fell by only $4.7 billion, or 10.6 percent. Yet, the economy boomed. The unemployment rate, which was artificially low at the end of the war because many millions of workers had been drafted into the U.S. armed services, did increase. But during the years from 1945 to 1948, it reached its peak at only 3.9 percent in 1946, and, for the months from September 1945 to December 1948, the average unemployment rate was only 3.5 percent.

Saturday, November 06, 2010

Survey on News Bias

With the mid-term election coming to close, it seems traditional media (TV, newspaper, magazine) has continued to be influential. They also continue to be biased. These two realities can be a problem, especially if we aren't aware of them. If you would please take a minute and label each news source by your perceived bias, not what you think most people will say. If you can't answer some, please feel free to leave them blank. I will post the results in one week. Your participation is greatly appreciated.

...

*The survey has been closed. Here are the results*

Friday, November 05, 2010

Where God and Libertarianism Meet

A main focus of my writing here has been my lack of faith in government and my firm belief in God. Apparently the two are may be connected:
when personal control is threatened, people defend external systems of control, such as God and government. This theoretical perspective also suggests that belief in God and support for governmental systems, although seemingly disparate, will exhibit a hydraulic relationship with one another. Using both experimental and longitudinal designs in Eastern and Western cultures, the authors demonstrate that experimental manipulations or naturally occurring events (e.g., electoral instability) that lower faith in one of these external systems (e.g., the government) lead to subsequent increases in faith in the other (e.g., God).

Thursday, November 04, 2010

Economics of The Simpsons

I recently posted on the Economics of Seinfeld. So here's some highlights from a paper, Homer Economicus, on one my other favorite TV comedies:

Bureaucrats and bureaucracy
As Gwartney, Stroup, Sobel and Macpherson (2003, 135) state, "Economic analysis suggests a strong tendency for bureaucrats and public-sector employees to favor expanding their budgets beyond what would be considered economically efficient." The Simpsons episode titled "Trash of the Titans," provides a great example of this tendency. After getting into an argument with the garbage men and refusing to apologize, Homer decides to run for Sanitation Commissioner. Running on the slogan "Can't someone else do it?" Homer wins and institutes a sanitation program that does just about everything for the residents of Springfield, from collecting diapers inside the house to cleaning their ties. This excessive spending leads to the following exchange between Homer and Mayor Quimby.

Quimby: Simpson, you idiot! You spent your entire year's budget in a month! Your department's broke!
Homer: Uh...oh no! Wait! I think I've got the perfect solution.
Quimby: You'd better! 'Cause those garbage men won't work for free!
Homer: D' oh!
Later, Homer and Marge are going over the sanitation department's expenses to figure out how he could have spent so much in such a short period of time.
Homer: Oh... [the previous commissioner] was right! I'm crashing and burning! Crashing and burning!
Marge: How could you spend 4.6 million dollars in a month?
Homer: They let me sign checks with a stamp, Marge! A stamp!

Although a bit over the top in that few (if any) bureaucrats are as stupid as Homer is portrayed to be, this episode of The Simpsons does provide a humorous beginning to a discussion of the incentives facing bureaucrats and bureaucracies.

The role of advertising in a market economy
Non-economists (and even some economists) tend to view most, if not all advertising as wasteful, misleading, manipulative, or a combination of all three. The previously mentioned episode of The Simpsons called "Trash of the Titans" provides a scene that ascribes to this viewpoint and can be used to begin discussion of the role that advertising plays in the market process.

The scene begins with a stereotypical cigar-smoking businessman in a dark room discussing with his staff the importance of finding a new holiday to exploit.

Businessman: Okay, people. We need to cook up a new holiday for the summer. Something with gifts, cards, assorted gougeables.
Woman: How about something religious? We had great penetration last spring with "Christmas II"!
Man: Ooh, I kno\v, Spendover -like Passover but less talk, more presents!
The company then creates "Love Day" and we cut to the Simpsons celebrating the holiday by exchanging presents. Homer receives a talking toy bear dressed in a suit of armor.
Bear: I'm Sir Loves-A-Lot! The bear who loves to love
Homer: They didn't have Lord Huggington?
Marge: It's the same basic bear, Homey.
Homer: [dejected] I guess.

I use this exchange to introduce a discussion of advertising in a market economy. Is it manipulative? Does it make us pay more for products that are functionally the same as other, cheaper products? What, exactly, are we paying for when we pay for a brand name?

Monopoly
The Springfield Nuclear Power Plant where Homer works provides an excellent opportunity to liven up discussions of monopoly. For example, When discussing why entry barriers are sometimes high, the Springfield Nuclear Power Plant provides a nice illustration of a case where monopolies exist because of economies of scale.

The power plant also provides a good opportunity for discussion of the factors that make some monopolies stronger than other monopolies. After all, it takes two conditions to make a market a monopoly (Gwartney et. al., 255) .The first, as we just discussed, is high barriers to entry such as economies of scale. The second condition is a well-defined product for which there are no close substitutes. Even products provided by a single seller have substitutes, however, even if that substitute is nothing. The degree of monopoly power, and hence the ability to take advantage of one's monopoly status, therefore depends heavily on the nwnber and appropriateness of substitutes.

In the episode titled "Who Shot Mr. Burns, Part 1," C. Montgomery Burns, the owner of Springfield Nuclear Power Plant, apparently felt that one of the kno\vn substitutes to electrical lighting was eroding too much of his monopoly power and resolved to take out the competition.

Smithers: Well, Sir, you've certairlly vanquished all your enemies: the elementary school, the local tavern, the old age home...you must be very proud.
Burns: [stuffing money into his wallet] No, not while my greatest nemesis still provides our customers with free light, heat and energy. I call this enemy...the sun. Since the beginning of time man has yeared to destroy the sun. I will do the next best thing... block it out!
Smithers: Good God!
Bums: Imagine it, Smithers: electrical1ights and heaters running all day long!
Smithers: But Sir! Every plant and tree will die, owls will deafen us with incessant hooting...the town's sundial \vill be useless. I don't want any part of this project; it's unconscionably fiendish.

In addition to being reminiscent of Bastiat's "A Petition" (1964), this episode provides an excellent opportunity to discuss what will happen to the short-run price and output ofMr. Burns' power plant, if his "fiendish" plan were to have worked.

Wednesday, November 03, 2010

Reason and Emotion Drive Market Efficiency

Earlier this year I posted about our two tools for decision making, reason and emotion. Justin Landwehr recently posted a great explanation of the idea:
This is where I think the camera analogy is very useful. If you think of emotions being like the automatic settings and you think of manual mode as being like reasoning, you can ask of a photographer, "What's better: the automatic settings or the manual mode?" And what the photographer will say is "different things are good for different circumstances" -- that if you are in a standard kind of photographic situation, the kind that the manufacturer of your camera could anticipate, then go ahead and use your automatic landscape setting or whatever. But if you're facing a fundamentally new kind of photographic challenge, then you are probably going to have to put your camera in manual mode.
It seems obvious that the manual mode in our brain is helpful. We do the mental math and calculate which decisions are best. This drives producers and consumers alike. Here's a description of an experiment showing how our automatic setting can hurt and help:
Montague’s experiments go like this: A subject is given $100 and some basic information about the stock market. After choosing how much money to invest, the player watches as his investments either rise or fall in value. The game continues for 20 rounds, and the subject gets to keep the money. One interesting twist is that instead of using random simulations of the market, Montague relies on real data from past markets, so people unwittingly “play” the Dow of 1929, the S&P 500 of 1987 and the Nasdaq of 1999. While the subjects are making their investment decisions, Montague measures the activity of neurons in the brain.
Here's the big reveal:
But then Montague discovered something strange. As the market continued to rise, these same neurons significantly reduced their rate of firing. “It’s as if the cells were getting anxious,” Montague says. “They knew something wasn’t right.” And then, just before the bubble burst, these neurons typically stopped firing altogether. In many respects, these dopamine neurons seem to be acting like an internal thermostat, shutting off when the market starts to overheat. Unfortunately, the rest of the brain is too captivated by the profits to care: instead of heeding the warning, the brain obeys the urges of so-called higher regions, like the prefrontal cortex, which are busy coming up with all sorts of reasons that the market will never decline. In other words, our primal emotions are acting rationally, while those rational circuits are contributing to the mass irrationality.

Tuesday, November 02, 2010

How to Increase Voting

I'm very interested in the culture of voting. I talked plenty about how your vote doesn't count, which helps explain why it's so hard to get people to vote. I've posted about how Swiss mail-in ballots decreased turnout. And here's Megan McArdle on how early voting may do the same. I even wrote my graduate thesis on the effects of compulsory voting laws. So when I read about a way to actually get people to vote, I couldn't resist. So what's this magical method? Peer pressure. Here's the story:
Before the 2006 Michigan gubernatorial primary, three political scientists isolated a group of voters and mailed them copies of their voting histories, listing the elections in which they participated and those they missed. Included were their neighbors’ voting histories, too, along with a warning: after the polls closed, everyone would get an updated set.

After the primary, the academics examined the voter rolls and were startled by the potency of peer pressure as a motivational tool. The mailer was 10 times better at turning nonvoters into voters than the typical piece of pre-election mail whose effectiveness has ever been measured.
My next question is, do we even want those pressure driven votes?

Monday, November 01, 2010

Emptying the Bottle: Early-November '10 Links

Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
As always, feel free to email me anything interesting you come across.