Sunday, September 19, 2010

Dealing With Other's Pain

So far I've been lucky. I've had very little loss in my life. So when I see others going through a crisis, the best response isn't always clear to me. Usual responses can vary between cliché sayings, shallow expressions of understanding, vague offers to help, or just helpless avoidance. A friend recently shared this article from the New York Times that says what I've heard my wife say before, be honest and be specific. Don't ask if there is anything you can do to help, the grieving don't always have the mental energy or patience to teach you how to love them. Instead, pick something that you think needs to be done (fix dinner, mow the lawn, drive their child to an appointment) and do it. The only responsibility of those in pain is to accept the help offered.

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Nudging Humans Toward Economists

I recently came across an article in the medical journal The Lancet about how economists try to understand humans:
Early in their engaging book, Nudge, Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein draw a distinction between Homo economicus, a species whose members they refer to as “econs”, and real people, whom they refer to as humans. “Homo economicus can think like Albert Einstein, store as much memory as IBM's Big Blue, and exercise the willpower of Mahatma Gandhi. Really.” Real humans do indeed have cool, computationally gifted, far-sighted, and ethical minds, but these “econ” brains are constantly at war with their much older lizard brains, the “hot”, programmed-to-win, and action-oriented system that controls affect, that wants stuff, and wants it now.
Adam Smith called it "passion" and John Maynard Keynes called it "animal spirits". I might call it the struggle between reason and emotion. Admittedly economists makes a lot of assumptions when talking about human action, but as the article points out, that's mostly good:
Current mainstream economics has many defenders and it has many successes despite (or some would argue because of) ignoring the passions. Thinking of people as greedy calculators does pretty well in many situations. The idea that I know what is good for me (even if frequently wrong) seems like the right starting place, certainly compared with having other people decide what is good for me.
If citizens aren't always rational, certainly politicians aren't either. However, often governments and businesses manipulate choices just by forcing you to make one. Citing the popular economics book Nudge (blog here), the article suggests making the "best" choice easier:
The most important is the “Save more tomorrow” scheme, in which employees sign a contract that will automatically increase their saving rate next year, at which time no action needs to be taken. At the very least, this nudge shows how a clever understanding of human psychology can help design light-touch institutions that help people do what they want to do, with no limit on their freedom to choose.
I can appreciate frustration with my own decisions (remember my New Year's Resolutions). I can also appreciate small (emphasis on small) nudges for a passionate/spirited/emotional people. Economics ignores a lot of reality in order to find some truth. If we try to explain everything we end up explaining nothing. Economics has been expanding into other social sciences and now they are expanding back. As long as economics doesn't lose what has made it grow, perhaps this mix can help us learn more about ourselves.

Friday, September 17, 2010

Reflection is the Best Medicine

Good relationship advice from Dr Oz's wife:
Because dealing with conflict is a large part of any long-term relationship [I agree], you need to know how to air your differences productively. Too often an argument devolves into proving you're right—and as I've learned, being right is overrated. One way to tell if you're resolving your disputes in a civilized manner is to record your argument, and then play it back later. Did you fight fair, or did you come off like the Wicked Witch of the West? I once saw a video of a family vacation that captured a fight Mehmet and I were having in the background. I was so horrified by my venomous tone, I quickly erased the tape—but seeing that fight is still having a positive impact on our relationship.
Even more, if you know the fight is on film, you'll probably play nicer.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Takeaways from Freakonomics, Part II

I finally got around to finishing the popular economics book Freakonomics, where "a rogue economist explores the hidden side of everything". You can read their current writing at the Freakonomics blog. You can find Part  I here. Here the last and second part of my takeaways, mostly about parenting and it's outcome:

The first couple of pages of the book make the now popular but still uncomfortable claim that the rise in abortions after Roe v. Wade in the 1970's led to a decrease in crime in the 1990's. Essentially, the unwanted babies were more likely to become criminals.

The American abortion statistics are shocking. In the first year after Roe v. Wade 750,000 women had abortions (1 for every 4 births). By 1980 the number was 1.6 million (1 for every 2.25 births). As of 2004, there have been 37 million abortions since Roe v. Wade.

The American story of abortion and crime is supported by a similar change in Romania.

Jane Roe (real name Norma McCorvey), from Roe v. Wade, converted to Christianity later in life and is now a adamant pro-life supporter.

More police and harsh punishment for laws is the best and easiest way to reduce crime.

The Broken windows theory of policing and the benefits of capital punishment are not supported by any data.

There needs to be, though there may not be, a better way for unwanted children to succeed.


Low income names are often normal names with weird spellings. Think Destinee, Bobbie, Tiffanie, etc.

Name popularity often goes from upper class, to middle class, to lower class. It seems a name's popularity is a signal for success, but the signal gets weaker as it becomes more popular. Maybe I should copy what  Mark Zuckerberg calls his kids.

Bad parenting matters more than good.

Race makes no difference in achievement (earlier). It only happens to be correlated with other things that do (parent income/education, mother's age at birth, etc).

Surprisingly, single parenthood does not effect achievement at school. Neither do stay-at-home moms (though both probably has other impacts).

IQ of biological parents matter more than IQ of adoptive parents in early academic performance.

Parents often determine their children's possibility through genetics, but peers do most of the influencing (earlier).

Low achieving adopted children did fare better as adults compared to those who stayed in a low achieving household.

What parents are matters more than what parents do. However, what parents do can eventually effect who parents are.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Bachelor Pad Game Theory

In case you missed it, the first season of The Bachelor Pad just ended. It is a Survivor-style reality TV show on ABC. It features losing contestants from previous seasons of The Bachelor and The Bachelorette competing for $250,000. Every week a series of dates, challenges, and votes determined who would stay and who would go. This week it was narrowed down to a final "couple", Dave and Natalie. The winner between the two of them was to be determined by a psychological experiment.

Dave and Natalie were forced to go into separate rooms and decide whether they wanted to "keep" or "share" the final prize. If they both picked “share”, the money would be split evenly between them ($125,000 each). If only one picked “share” and the other "keep”, the keeper gets the entire prize ($250,000) and the other, we'll call them the weeper, gets nothing. If they both pick "keep", then neither gets the cash and it is split among the other losing contestants (about $14,000 each). Sound familiar? It should. It's the famous Prisoner's Dilemma.

Here's how the experiment is usually described. Two criminals are arrested without much evidence and so are put in separate rooms. Each prisoner is offered the same deal that if they confess before their partner in crime does, they will receive no punishment and the other will go to jail. If they both confess they will both go to jail. However, because there is not much evidence, if neither confesses, there is only a small punishment. In this situation, how should the prisoners act? Or back to our original story, what should Dave and Natalie do? A little game theory, or strategy accounting for others' strategy, should help:




















As the matrix above shows, red player's best choice, no matter what the blue player does, is always to defect. The same is true for the blue player. So in our reality TV example, no matter what Dave chooses, Natalie is best off is she chooses to "keep" the money. The same is true for Dave. So did they act like the completely rational, completely self-interested, Homo economicus? No. In fact, both Dave and Natalie chose to split the money. I must admit, I would not have predicted that. However, I think I can explain why.

In the original Prisoner's Dilemma, the offer is made while both are separated. On the Bachelor Pad, the rules were explained while both contestants were sitting next to each other. Immediately they both made eye contact, as if to reassure each other of their relationship. If they were not allowed that moment, I'm not so sure the outcome would have been the same. Also, the original game takes place in a private interrogation room. The Bachelor Pad finale was watched by millions. Sometimes money isn't the only cost calculated. Overall show quality aside, it made for a pretty good ten minutes of television (watch here).

Hat tip to Lessons Learned Over Dinner (earlier).

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Naming Your Blog

As someone who changed their original blog name to something else, this made me smile:
I told them I wanted my blog there to be called Free Beer. They laughed. I said, “No. Really.” I told them that the title of a blog only matters the first time you see it listed somewhere. After that the title is irrelevant—you go to a blog because of a good recommendation, not because of a good name.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Takeaways from Freakonomics, Part I

I finally got around to finishing the popular economics book Freakonomics, where "a rogue economist explores the hidden side of everything". You can read their current writing at the Freakonomics blog. Here is Part I of my takeaways, mostly the economics parts:

The book itself was created by an unlikely duo, willing to work together. Is this how you create something truly unique?

As computers get better at doing things humans used to do (play chess, marketing, copilots) will they ever write our non-fiction for us?

Economics begins (with Adam Smith) at the same time capitalism begins. The two are intertwined.

An idea from Adam Smith: Man's morality comes from our ability to think as an objective third party.

If morality attempts to explain a perfect world, economics attempts to explain the real world.

An incentive is something small that changes something big.

There are three kinds of incentives: economic, social, and moral. All impact each other.

Real estate agents keep their own homes on the market for 10 days longer than average at a profit of 3% above average.

How to tell if what you're buying is really worth it. Are the descriptions vague and hard to prove or are they actually descriptive of the quality of the product.

Most drug dealers aren't rich. I've posted about this Freakonomics research before.

There are four meanful factors to job pay:
1) Number of other workers (available labor)
2) Number of possible workers (skills needed)
3) Unpleasantness of a job
4) Demand for the services provided

In 1987 when the IRS required the listing of social security numbers, not just names, of dependents, suddenly there were 7 million less children in America (1/10 of the total number of children).

Others' happiness makes us happy. So why don't I spend more time trying to make people happy?

Information is powerful. The KKK was partially taken from power by exposing the stupid secrets and privileges they enjoyed.

The lack of information produces fear.

Most people fear the unknown small danger more than the known large danger. Compare our fear of guns to our fear of swimming pools (3X as many children die in pools).

Good economic questions are unusual when proposed and obvious when explained.

Popular economics is figuring out what individuals have already figured out, just in reverse.

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Emptying the Bottle: Mid-September '10 Links

Here is a list of the worthwhile sites I've Bookmarked recently:
To follow live and to see comments, subscribe via Google Reader.

Saturday, September 11, 2010

September 11, 2001 in Video

I'm never clear on how to memorialize tragic events. We don't want to forget them, but we also don't want to trivialize their memory. Here's how I chose to re-remember September 11th.

WARNING: This material is extremely shocking and graphic in nature. The footage at 6 minutes and 30 seconds is especially sobering.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Empowering Powerless Parents

I've been hearing a lot about this topic lately and have been meaning to discuss it. Luckily, Justin did the leg work for me:
Gladwell's article states that about half of the personality differences among people come from genes (received from their parents, obviously), and half come from the environment. Harris argues that the latter half is dominated by a child's social network, and points to evidence that children tend to model their behavior after their peers, not their parents, particularly when outside the home.
That sums up nicely what economist Bryan Caplan has been saying for a while. This also contradicts how many parents talk about their children. Often they only discuss the positive accomplishments of their family, seemingly praising them. My guess is what they are actually doing is praising themselves for doing such a good job parenting. Instead have kids and enjoy them. Don't worry so much about how they will turn out, you probably have less day to day influence than you think. That said, if the pressure isn't on parents, but on peers in school, perhaps I'm more responsible then I think in my classroom.

Related: Which economist parenting style do you prefer, Bryan Caplan or Steve Levitt?