Various fearsome characters will soon be chanting "trick or treat" at doors all over America. That peculiar threat would seem to be a long way from the dismal science, but actually, Halloween reflects economics' central precept that people choose by comparing the benefits and costs they expect to bear as a result.Happy Halloween!Modern jack-o-lanterns are carved out of pumpkins because of economics, for example. They originated in Ireland as hollowed-out turnips, but pumpkins were more plentiful in America and made better lanterns, so immigrants carried on their tradition with pumpkins instead.
Dark houses and scary costumes originate from benefit-cost comparisons. In the fifth century B.C., Celts celebrated their New Year -- Samhain -- on October 31. According to legend, on that day the spirits of those who had died during the year searched for living bodies to possess as their only hope of an afterlife. Therefore, they made themselves unattractive "candidates." Houses were left dark, cold and undesirable, and people dressed ghoulishly to scare away the "shopping" spirits.
Trick-or-treating has economic roots. It originated with "souling" in ninth century Europe. On All Soul's Day, poor Christians would go door-to-door asking for "soul cakes"-- bread studded with currants. The more cakes they received, the more prayers they would say for the donor's dead relatives. This theological exchange of bread for prayers was viable because of the belief that prayers by the faithful could hasten their passage to heaven.
Current Halloween practices also reflect economics. Second only to Christmas as a shopping holiday, Halloween generates about $5 billion in sales, reflecting the three-fourths of Americans who mark the occasion in some way. It is the biggest payday for candy makers, who have turned when daylight savings time "falls back" into a major issue, in search of added sales from an extra hour of trick-or-treating.
Because Halloween is the biggest night for costume rentals and purchases and behind only New Year's and the Super Bowl for alcohol sales, sellers in these industries pray for a weekend Halloween so more adult parties will take place. The Halloween Association trade group even proposed permanently making Halloween the last Saturday in October, to get more economic bang out of the holiday.
Halloween is one of many children's first experiences with economic decision-making. How long should you continue to trick or treat? You stop when the costs in terms of tiredness and sore feet outweigh the benefits of the additional candy take. Is it really worth walking to the dentist's house to get a toothbrush? Which streets should you hit? That reflects costs (how far do I have to walk?) versus likely treat benefits. The number of lights on, the income level and number of kids in the neighborhood all enter this calculation, and children learn to ask others about a street's loot before heading down it. Some parents even drive their children to other neighborhoods to increase their trick-or-treat haul. When are you too old to trick or treat? When the cost of the hassles you get about it outweigh the benefits of the candy you expect. Children staying with friends Halloween night also learn how markets work, via candy exchange negotiations.
The economics of Halloween affects others as well. Homeowners learn why the trick-or-treater's dream -- a bowl of candy with a sign saying "take all you want" -- doesn't work very well. Primary school teachers are much more likely to call in sick after Halloween because the children are either still going to be on their sugar high or suffering from the low that follows, and what meager learning will take place doesn't justify the cost of containing the pandemonium.
Economics may be the dismal science. But it can shed real insight even on "non-economic" matters such as Halloween. And the fact that we extort treats with threats of tricks the same month that the federal fiscal year begins and just before major elections is also a useful analytical reminder.
Saturday, October 31, 2009
Economics of Halloween
Or should I call it, Eekonomics:
Friday, October 30, 2009
Support for Winter Tanning
The news is full of flu reports and suggestions (wash your hands). But why is the flu more likely in the winter? My first reaction was because it's cold, which actually doesn't make any sense. The real reason is a little more rational:
Just as flu season gathers force here in the northern hemisphere, it’s petering out in the southern half of the globe. No matter where you are, you’re more susceptible to the flu in the winter months. Even if, let’s say, some research physicians expose you to live flu virus in the middle of summer, you’re still less likely to get sick than if the same doctors hit you with the same virus in the dead of winter. Why? One big risk factor for flu infection is a lack of vitamin D. We naturally produce vitamin D when we’re exposed to sunlight, and as the days shorten in the winter, we produce less and less of it.
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Best of 60-Second Sciences
I try to give updates to worthwhile blogs I've come across. The Scientific American has some great podcasts that give interesting science news in 60-seconds. Here's some good ones:
- Birds apparently dialects and noise pollution forces them to change
- The internet is good exercise for your brain
- Humor preferences are based on unconscious personal truths
- Birth control pill change women's preferences for men
- Apparently knowledge isn't power
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
See Me Do Comedy
I've mentioned before that I perform comedy improv at the Dirty South Improv Theater, so I figured I give the details in case you're ever in the mood. My profile page has breif history of my experience and a running feed of nights I'm preforming. I am currently on three teams:
- Mister Diplomat: Features true stories told by a local celebrity to inspire a fully improvised two half show. This is a free ($0) show every Friday at 9:30.
- Pound for Pound: Two person show with Paula Pazderka. From a single suggestion we create 25 minute series of scenes. Usually once a month on Saturday nights for $10.
- The 708: This is a house team that specifically performs a Harold. We perform once a month on Friday nights for $10.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
Most Art Isn't Worth It, But Some Is
For a while I've been wrestling with the idea that a majority of improv comedy isn't worth seeing. I say this not with any particular person, group, or theater in mind, but with my 5 years of experience performing and seeing thousands of scenes. In response an old improv friend, Jeremiah Jones, said that most art, not just improv, is not worth paying for. Bad music, paintings, books, etc. are just as common as bad improvisation. As pessimistic as that sounds, it has actually convinced me to continue my pursuit of live comedy. Maybe one day I can be the Beethoven, Picasso or J.K. Rowling of improv comedy.
Monday, October 26, 2009
Blog Posts I'd Like to Read
In celebration of this being my 300th blog post, here are some ideas I want to see discussed, and I can't find a good place that completely covers the issue. Feel free to respond in the comments, on your own blog, or just point me to someone who's done it already:
- Why I'm Not a libertarian - I am, but why aren't you (and most of America)?
- Compound Interest vs. Social Security - mathematically compare the future value
- How Our Grandkids Will Live - technology and culture changes, tell me how
- Problem with High School Teachers - describe what you remember wanting more/less of
- Why I Don't Blog - I do, but why don't you (and most of America)?
Sunday, October 25, 2009
Ignorance as a Placebo
Placebos are something that have always intrigued me. It seems our brain can make us feel better when it expects that it should. The Placebo Effect has even gotten more powerful as real drugs have gotten more effective. Not only that, but the improvement from fake pills can be different based on what the person thinks they are taking. If we feel better after taking a sugar pill that we think is real, then maybe we feel less sick if we don't know we're sick. Can ignorance itself be a placebo? If so, maybe this explains why so many people fear going to the doctor. Bad health news may actually create bad health. Anyone with a better understanding of science help me out?
Saturday, October 24, 2009
Difference Between Humans and Animals
I've discussed before about my proof of the inherent value of animals. But if you were asked what differentiates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom, what would you say? Intelligence? Language? Sacrifice? Hobbies? Controlling nature? Ability to use tools? To my knowledge, all of those aren't true. All animals have some level of intelligence, there's even a blog dedicated to it (funny example). If language is the expression of thoughts through sounds or gestures, many animals do that. Here's a Wikipedia list of animal altruism. Here's a story about orangutans knocking trees down just to play a near death game of dodging them. Don't tell beavers you don't think they subdue nature. And here's a link to several examples of animals using tools. Humans may be able to do these things better, but that doesn't seem to make us unique.
The one thing that I used to think humans did that animals didn't, was trade. Taxpayers pay me to teach their high school students and in return I use that money to buy food, clothes, etc. But it seems even this assumption was wrong:
They both use their labor and capital to work together for a mutually beneficial trade. The second half of that video even shows some animals have an understanding of fairness. So what is it that separates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom? Relationship. Intimate, long lasting, trusting, educational relationships. Human beings, using that long list of things we do better (language, sacrifice, hobbies, tools, etc), are able to create complex societies of cooperation. It is for this reason humans are able to have culture, art, and even religion. Here's one last experiment that will both show you what I mean (listen to the explanation at the end):
The one thing that I used to think humans did that animals didn't, was trade. Taxpayers pay me to teach their high school students and in return I use that money to buy food, clothes, etc. But it seems even this assumption was wrong:
They both use their labor and capital to work together for a mutually beneficial trade. The second half of that video even shows some animals have an understanding of fairness. So what is it that separates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom? Relationship. Intimate, long lasting, trusting, educational relationships. Human beings, using that long list of things we do better (language, sacrifice, hobbies, tools, etc), are able to create complex societies of cooperation. It is for this reason humans are able to have culture, art, and even religion. Here's one last experiment that will both show you what I mean (listen to the explanation at the end):
Friday, October 23, 2009
Emptying the Bottle: Late-October '09 Bookmarks
Here is a summary of the Google shared items from worthwhile sites I've found lately:
- Why Some May Have No Future
- Acronyms Sometimes Suck: breakthrough urban ministries
- Markets In Everything: $500,000 Twitter Ad?
- Obama is Going Galt
- Managing 703 feeds
- Successful government bureaucracies
- How to Blog in One Slide
- Marginal Revolution: Green jobs
- The Internet has created a generation of great writers
- If You Tax Something You Get Less of It, Even Rich People
Thursday, October 22, 2009
Corporate Welfare vs. Business Friendly
One of the big North Carolina news stories recently has been the closing of the Dell plant in Winston-Salem. The controversy comes from the quarter million dollars in tax breaks given to Dell in 2004 so they would come to the area. Dell will have to give some of that money back, so it's not a total loss, but that doesn't change the impact this will have on the city. The main lesson to take away from this is how unpredictable corporate welfare is. Giving money to businesses to come to your area is not guaranteed to bring a net benefit. And even if it does bring a large employer, the chances of that business staying, or even existing, forever is small. When that large company goes away, so do the jobs it offered (at least in the short run). For a city to be so dependent on one company is risky, just ask Detroit. The real way to improve the local economy is to create a business friendly atmosphere (simple/low taxes, low crime, hard working/educated workforce). You don't need big business to thrive. After all, 99.9% of all companies have less than 500 employees. So why are these incentives so common? It may not help the local economy, but it does help the local politician.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
.jpg)